Well, it seems like the whole Dixie Chicks thing has finally blown over, and I say good riddance. I got so tired of hearing people berate the band and their music because of one off-hand comment made during a London concert. Granted, it was a really stupid thing to say, but the reaction was blown completely out of proportion.
Here’s why what Natalie Maines said really doesn’t matter: WHO CARES?!? Who really cares what Natalie Maines thinks about current events or world politics? What gave her opinion any credence? She’s a singer. Geez. You would probably hear a lot worse on any Washington, DC street corner.
Why is it that when someone makes a little money, and garners a bit of spotlight, suddenly America thinks that whatever their opinion is on anything, it’s worth listening to? Hollywood stars testifying before Congress? Pages and pages of news coverage over a singer’s off-hand comment? Everyone’s entitled to their opinion (I like mine; that’s why I have this blog
, but are we as Americans incapable of showing any discrimination? Do we find it impossible to tell the difference between the opinions of, say, William Safire or George F. Will and Natalie Maines? That possibility scares me greatly.
The other side of this situation is that the Dixie Chicks thought their opinion mattered, too. They — like most popular singers, actors, etc today — view themselves as artists, with the whole misunderstood / tortured / apart from the world / not bound by normal rules image that goes along with that label. The fact is, they are not artists; they are a commodity. They may not like this fact, but that is the truth, and the sooner they accept it, the better off they’ll be (denying reality is never healthy).
By the way, I personally like the Dixie Chick’s music. Wide Open Spaces is one of my favorite country songs; I think it so aptly captures the feel of North and West Texas; both the lyrics and the music complement each other so well. Still, just because I like their music doesn’t mean I care about their politics.